Are Bamboo Rods As Good As Carbon Fiber Ones?
June 10th, 2009 | Uncategorized | No Comments »Can an old fishing rod actually compete with the best modern day cf rods? This problem has perplexed many avid fishermen, especially those with a fondness for fly fishing or spinning. Is there value in seeking out and purchasing an antique or vintage rod?
Well, it is pretty much linked to what kind of fishing you are interested in. Fiberglass rods have long since been surpassed by cf or carbon fiber fishing poles. So buying an old fiberglass rod would be a waste of money. Also, many old rods that have been used extensively have invariably sustained damage of one kind or another, and such damage may have compromised the strength and integrity of the rod. Who would want to take the chance that such a rod would not break under the strain of a trophy-sized fish?
Split cane fishing rods and other poles created from bamboo, on the other hand, are a different kettle of fish. There are many anglers that say that even with the latest progress in modern fishing rod manufacture, a state-of-the-art carbon fiber rod cannot match the action, flexibility and durability of a split cane fishing rod. In particular, where accurate and long casting of light weights is paramount, cane rods seem to have the edge. Another important consideration for many is the appearance of a quality vintage cane rod, which more closely resembles a piece of artwork than just another piece of fishing gear.
Suitability For Fishing
An antique cane pole would thereby appear to be very suitable for anyone who enjoys fly fishing or spinning, particularly on sheltered bodies of water free of strong winds, currents and tides. Of course, the same rule applies: a damaged rod is no good for fishing. Therefore you must check the bamboo sections carefully. Discoloration, water marks, scratches, crushes, holes and other significant damage are things to keep an eye out for. If the bamboo is sound, and the price is right, the rod could well be worth purchasing. Most of the other fittings on a cane fishing rod can be restored to their original condition for a modest sum, so do not panic if the whippings are frayed or the ferrules are a little loose. Catching the fish species it was designed for will present no difficulties if the rod you have bought has been restored to its original state, or if bought in very good condition.
One of the most renowned brands of bamboo rods is Milwards of England. Their unequalled level of build, finish, flexibility and kit made Milwards rods stand apart from others of their generation. Standard Milwards fittings included brass ferrules, silver guides with agate rings, cork handles and silk threads. Milwards fly fishing and spinning rods were designed to fit into specific fishing niches and therefore were often excellent match rods. For example, the FloatMaster was perfect for casting float rigs, while the Milwards SwimVersa was magnificent at casting extremely lightweight baits or lures Milwards split cane fishing rods are highly valued but occasionally come on the market. One way of obtaining one is by enticing the owner to swap it to you in exchange for a vintage piece of fishing tackle of similar value.
So although a fiberglass rod is no subsitute for a modern cf one, a split cane fishing rod may well perform better in certain environments and for certain fish species. Cane rods can also look great just adorning the wall of your living room, study or den. The decision whether or not to go with a sound vintage fishing rod is not that difficult at all when it comes down to it!